Skip to content
Join our Newsletter

It’s time to rethink how we enforce the rules of the road

Mulling over bright lights, red lights, roundabouts and ICBC
Columnist Michael Geller suspects dimmer headlights, more traffic cameras, roundabouts and driver re
Columnist Michael Geller suspects dimmer headlights, more traffic cameras, roundabouts and driver re-testing would lead to fewer car accidents. Photo Dan Toulgoet

Have you noticed vehicle headlights getting brighter?

At first, I thought the problem was my advancing years. But having been recently blinded by a shiny new Mercedes driving down Blenheim Street, I pulled over and Googled “are car headlights too bright?” I was pleased to read I am not the only one concerned about the intensity of new headlights.

From an online forum: “Is it my eyes or are some car headlights too bright?” And the LA Times: “It’s not your imagination, headlights are getting brighter.”

From the UK Daily Mail: “Wondering why headlights are so painfully blinding?”

From CBS in New York: “Drivers say bright headlights are creating a dangerous situation.”

At a time when car accidents and insurance rates are in the news, I can’t help but believe blinding headlights may be causing some accidents.

My wife and I both drive cars with bright new headlights. I know because occasionally drivers flash their high beams assuming I’m on high beams, when I am not.

As we debate how best to reduce vehicle accidents and insurance costs, I hope ICBC will investigate whether blinding headlights are causing not only discomfort for motorists, but also accidents.

Blinding headlights are not my only traffic concern.

No doubt due to increasing traffic congestion and longer commutes, an increasing number of drivers are running red lights. 

At the same time, many motorists oppose installation of more red-light cameras, or 24-hour operation of the 140 cameras currently in place at the province’s most accident-prone intersections.

That’s right. Currently, many red-light cameras are only operated six hours a day since previous governments did not want to upset voters.

Listening to a recent radio phone-in program, I was disturbed by how many listeners opposed red-light cameras, even at dangerous intersections. Presumably, they equate them with photo radar, which was often viewed as a cash cow, rather than accident prevention.

Given the increasing number of traffic accidents and fatalities, and yes, increasing insurance costs, I think it is time to rethink our attitudes towards enforcing the rules of the road.

Perhaps we should follow the lead of Scotland and implement a safety camera program that operates both speed and red-light cameras across the country. Scottish red-light cameras are programed to not only catch those running red lights, but also speeding drivers.

This brings me to an alternative to intersections and red lights. Traffic roundabouts and circles.

Having lived in the U.K. and driven in many European countries, I am a fan of roundabouts. I even installed two at SFU’s UniverCity. However, every time I approach a small Vancouver traffic circle, which is essentially a glorified uncontrolled intersection, I worry whether oncoming drivers know who has the right-of-way.

In case you are not sure, if two vehicles arrive at a traffic circle or roundabout at the same time, the vehicle on the right has the right to enter first. Cyclists should be treated like a vehicle.

The recent revelations about increased traffic accidents and major ICBC losses due to injury claims were very disturbing. They were also somewhat surprising.

Since cars are increasingly designed with safety in mind, with multiple air bags, back-up cameras and side mirror warnings, I would have expected the number of injuries to be reduced.

However, I have also observed that many motorists do not appear to know how to drive properly. They stay in the passing lane and refuse to pull over to allow other motorists to pass. While they may not be in accidents, they cause accidents.

Others take little notice of upcoming pedestrian crossings, refuse to stop before turning right on a red light, and seem to have forgotten the concept of “defensive driving.”

One solution may be more regular road testing for drivers. My generation hasn’t been tested since the 1960s. Perhaps it should be mandatory for anyone deemed to have caused a serious accident to be re-tested before they can drive again.

If Motor Vehicle Testing Stations do not have adequate capacity for more regular road tests, ICBC could set up independent accredited testers.

While no doubt many will see this as just another cash grab, I see it as a way to make driving safer.

@michaelgeller

geller@sfu.ca