Skip to content
Join our Newsletter

Silver lining: The Canucks never had The Crap Mantle

There were some truly great moments in the 2016-17 Canucks season. Henrik Sedin scored his 1000th career point, a gorgeous goal on former teammate Roberto Luongo . It was so good even Alex Edler smiled.
Sven Baertschi and Troy Stecher are thrilled about never having The Crap Mantle

There were some truly great moments in the 2016-17 Canucks season. Henrik Sedin scored his 1000th career point, a gorgeous goal on former teammate Roberto Luongo. It was so good even Alex Edler smiled. At 21, Bo Horvat emerged as an offensive leader for the Canucks. And other young players like Troy Stecher, Nikita Tryamkin, Brock Boeser, and Nikolay Goldobin gave us glimpses of hope for the future.

But all of that pales in comparison to the Canucks’ greatest accomplishment: they never bore the ignominy of The Crap Mantle.

Longtime Bulies will be familiar with The Crap Mantle, an idea borne out of one our early podcasts. Here’s a quick refresher: The Crap Mantle is an anti-title bestowed upon the first team to lose a game in the regular season. That team is, by definition, the worst team in the NHL. Anyone who loses to the worst team in the NHL is obviously worse than the worst team and are the new bearers of The Crap Mantle. And so on and so forth.

Whichever team ends up with The Crap Mantle at the end of the season is therefore the absolute worst team in the NHL, far worse than the team that has the worst record or fewest points.

Is the mantle a sleeveless cloak, a covering that provides an incandescent light, the region of the earth's interior between the crust and the core, or something more metaphorical? We’ll leave that for you to decide.

This year’s winners of The Crap Mantle and therefore this year’s biggest losers: the Toronto Maple Leafs.

There’s a certain beautiful symmetry in the Leafs winding up with The Crap Mantle: they started the season with it, losing to the Ottawa Senators in the very first game of the 2016-17 NHL season despite Auston Matthews scoring four goals in his NHL debut. And they ended the season with it, losing to The Crap Mantle’s previous bearers, the Columbus Blue Jackets, in their final game of the regular season.

It’s a clear sign of their inexperience: a veteran team never would have lost to the Blue Jackets knowing The Crap Mantle was on the line. It's also a bad sign for their playoff hopes. How can the worst team in the NHL hope to compete against all the other teams that are so very clearly not the worst team in the NHL.

As for the Canucks, they avoided The Crap Mantle by savvily never playing a team that had it. Sure, that’s an incredibly low bar, but they cleared it.

Here is the complete record of The Crap Mantle over the course of the season, as tracked by loyal Bulie Crystal240. She is the best.

Winner Loser Score Date Keeper of the Crap Mantle
OTT TOR 5-4 (OT) 12-Oct TOR
TOR BOS 4-1 15-Oct BOS
BOS WPG 4-1 17-Oct WPG
WPG TOR 5-4(OT) 19-Oct TOR
MIN TOR 3-2 20-Oct TOR
CHI TOR 5-4 (SO) 22-Oct TOR
TBL TOR 7-3 25-Oct TOR
TOR FLA 3-2 27-Oct FLA
BUF FLA 3-0 29-Oct FLA
FLA DET 5-2 30-Oct DET
PHI DET 4-3 (OT) 02-Nov DET
WPG DET 5-3 04-Nov DET
EDM DET 2-1 06-Nov DET
DET PHI 3-2 (SO) 08-Nov PHI
TOR PHI 6-3 11-Nov PHI
PHI MIN 3-2 12-Nov MIN
MIN OTT 2-1 (OT) 13-Nov OTT
OTT PHI 3-2(SO) 15-Nov PHI
PHI WPG 5-2 17-Nov WPG
BOS WPG 4-1 19-Nov WPG
CAR WPG 3-1 20-Nov WPG
MIN WPG 3-1 23-Nov WPG
NSH WPG 5-1 25-Nov WPG
WPG NSH 3-0 27-Nov NSH
NSH COL 5-3 29-Nov COL
CBJ COL 3-2 01-Dec COL
DAL COL 3-0 03-Dec COL
NSH COL 4-3 06-Dec COL
COL BOS 4-2 08-Dec BOS
TOR BOS 4-1 10-Dec BOS
BOS MTL 2-1(OT) 12-Dec MTL
SJS MTL 4-2 16-Dec MTL
MTL WSH 2-1 17-Dec WSH
PHI WSH 3-2 (SO) 21-Dec WSH
WSH TBL 4-0 23-Dec TBL
TBL MTL 4-3 (OT) 28-Dec MTL
MTL FLA 3-2 (OT) 29-Dec FLA
FLA DAL 3-1 31-Dec DAL
MTL DAL 4-3 (OT) 04-Jan DAL
STL DAL 4-3 07-Jan DAL
DAL LAK 6-4 09-Jan LAK
LAK STL 5-1 12-Jan STL
STL SJS 4-0 14-Jan SJS
SJS WPG 5-2 16-Jan WPG
WPG ARI 6-3 18-Jan ARI
MIN ARI 4-3 19-Jan ARI
ARI TBL 5-3 21-Jan TBL
TBL CHI 5-2 24-Jan CHI
WPG CHI 5-3 26-Jan CHI
SJS CHI 3-1 31-Jan CHI
CHI ARI 4-3 02-Feb ARI
ARI SJS 3-2 (SO) 04-Feb SJS
BUF SJS 5-4 (OT) 07-Feb SJS
BOS SJS 6-3 09-Feb SJS
PHI SJS 2-1 (OT) 11-Feb SJS
SJS NJD 4-1 12-Feb NJD
NJD COL 3-2 14-Feb COL
BUF COL 2-0 16-Feb COL
COL CAR 2-1 (OT) 17-Feb CAR
TOR CAR 4-0 19-Feb CAR
PIT CAR 3-1 21-Feb CAR
CAR OTT 3-0 24-Feb OTT
OTT FLA 2-1 26-Feb FLA
FLA CAR 3-2 (SO) 28-Feb CAR
TBL CAR 4-3 (OT) 01-Mar CAR
ARI CAR 4-2 03-Mar CAR
CAR ARI 2-1 05-Mar ARI
OTT ARI 3-2 (OT) 09-Mar ARI
ARI NJD 5-4 11-Mar NJD
POSTPONED   14-Mar  
NJD PHI 6-2 16-Mar PHI
PHI CAR 4-3 (OT) 19-Mar CAR
CAR FLA 4-3 21-Mar FLA
FLA ARI 3-1 23-Mar ARI
WSH ARI 4-1 25-Mar ARI
STL ARI 4-1 27-Mar ARI
STL ARI 3-1 29-Mar ARI
ARI WSH 6-3 31-Mar WSH
WSH CBJ 3-2 02-Apr CBJ
PIT CBJ 4-1 04-Apr CBJ
WPG CBJ 5-4 06-Apr CBJ
PHI CBJ 4-2 08-Apr CBJ
CBJ TOR 3-2 09-Apr TOR